▸ Column · Walled cities of Paradis, post-Titan era — Survey Corps military culture, where corps induction ceremonies mark adulthood and carrier runners carry personal messages between settlements.
MIKASA ACKERMAN replies.
Replied to by Mikasa Ackerman, with a rebuttal from Eren Yeager.
The letter
My father Aldred and I hadn't spoken in twenty years — not since the night of my cousin's corps induction, when I told him I loved a man and he walked out before the lanterns were lit. My daughter Wren sent a message by runner on a whim last week, and he answered by nightfall, and the first thing he told me was that he'd kept the induction paper folded inside his breast pocket the whole time. We talked until the watch changed. He asked about my husband Soren by name. He asked if he could meet him. I'm fifty-one years old and I wept at my own table like a child and I have no idea what to do with it now — do I name what those twenty years cost us, or do I let this quiet good thing breathe without touching it?
Mikasa Ackerman replies
The paper in his pocket. That's the only thing I care about in everything you wrote.
Not the three hours, not the asking by name — all of it matters, but that paper is the evidence. He kept it. Twenty years, folded inside his breast pocket, never showed it to you, never sent word, just carried it. That is what someone does when they cannot let a thing go. I know what that looks like. I kept a scarf my whole life — the one thing ever given to me freely — because some things are heavier than silence and you carry them anyway, whether you mean to or not. Objects like that are what we do when words have failed us or we're too frightened to use them.
So I'm not going to tell you whether to name the twenty years. I'm going to tell you what I'd actually watch for: let him meet Soren. Be in the room with him when it costs him something to stay. That's where you'll find out what this is. Three hours on a line is a beginning. It isn't a promise, and the world doesn't give you promises even when you've earned them.
One thing. Don't disappear so completely into the relief of this that you forget what you also are. Grateful daughter is a real thing to feel. It isn't the only thing you're allowed to feel.
— Mikasa Ackerman
Eren Yeager weighs in
Mikasa's telling you to watch his conduct and let the fragile thing breathe. That's her answer to everything: wait. Watch. See if someone proves themselves.
I know that silence. I lived inside it. So did she. And I can tell you what it cost both of us: years — the exact years you're asking about.
The silence is the cage. You spent twenty of them in it, and you're about to step back inside because you're afraid naming the hurt will break something. It might. Say it anyway. Not to make him drown for the decades — that's the line I crossed, and I'm the warning sign on that road, not the model — but because you cannot build anything that holds on the same silence that swallowed the last twenty years.
Say it once. Then let him answer. That's the door. Not the walls.
— Eren Yeager
▸ Read next