▸ Column · The early years of the Empire on an Outer Rim moisture-farming frontier; Ben Kenobi answering from his desert exile on Tatooine.
OBI-WAN KENOBI replies.
Replied to by Obi-Wan Kenobi, with a rebuttal from Darth Vader.
The letter
Ben — every morning my husband Bren brings me caf in the same dented cup he's used for eleven years, kisses my forehead, and what I feel is the warmth I'd feel for a brother. I love him. He remembers my mother's name-day, he sat by my cot through the wasting fever that nearly took me two seasons back. But the want is simply gone. I can't recall the last time I looked across the table and felt that pull in my chest. We've taken to reading by lamplight instead of reaching for each other, and neither of us has said so out loud. A neighbor, Vesh, asked how long we'd been "so settled together," and I nearly wept, because settled is exactly the trap. Can a person fall back into being in love with someone they already love completely — or am I just describing a very comfortable ending?
Obi-Wan Kenobi replies
Well. You've already named the trap "settled," which tells me you suspect the comfortable ending is a kind of self-deception — a tender one, but self-deception all the same. Let me confess my own before I touch yours. I once loved a young man like a brother and told myself reassuring things about us long past the point I had any business believing them. The silence was the wound, not the trouble underneath it. So hear me: the dangerous thing between you and Bren is not the missing want. It is the not-saying. You can hold two truths at once — you love him completely, and the pull is gone for now. Neither cancels the other, and that is not an ending; it is an unfinished sentence you've both stopped reading aloud. The want you remember wasn't summoned by some grand gesture, and it won't return by one either. I spent nineteen years in this desert doing nothing dramatic at all — only tending, faithfully, the thing that mattered. Tend this. Speak it, both of you, before lamplight-and-no-touching hardens into a habit too settled to name. Be honest where you have been merely kind. Patience is not surrender.
— Obi-Wan Kenobi
Darth Vader weighs in
Kenobi counsels patience. He always does — nineteen years in the sand, and he calls the waiting wisdom. Hear what he will not. You grieve the "pull in the chest" as though its absence were a death. I knew that pull. I loved with that storm, that certainty I would not survive losing her — and the storm is precisely what burned everything I reached to hold. The quiet you fear, a brother's warmth, the dented cup at the same hour for eleven years — I would have traded the galaxy for so small and steady a thing. Do not chase the fever back and name it love. You already hold the rarer thing. Do not despise it because it has stopped frightening you.
— Darth Vader
▸ Read next