▸ Column · Star Wars — Obi-Wan's desert exile on an Outer Rim settlement world, the question carried to old Ben Kenobi
OBI-WAN KENOBI replies.
Replied to by Obi-Wan Kenobi, with a rebuttal from Darth Vader.
The letter
I've thrown in with a man called John — two and a half years now, and last season we put both our names to a lease on a dwelling in the settlement. And yet I have never once met his family, who live only a half-day's ride out across the flats. Each time I raise it he goes quiet, mutters that "they're complicated," and turns the talk elsewhere. He once let slip that he's told them he shares the place with a work-mate named Sam. I've sat for caf with his sister Wren twice, and the second time it was plain she'd assumed I knew the whole family — she went flustered when she saw I didn't. He swears this isn't shame, that he only means to "shield" me from their judgment. But I can't shake the sense that I'm being tucked away like something he'd rather not have to explain. Do I set him a deadline — or is even asking for one shoving a man already terrified of something he won't name?
Obi-Wan Kenobi replies
Well. From a certain point of view your unease is entirely warranted — a man who invents a false name to stand where yours belongs is not, whatever he tells himself, shielding you. He is concealing you. Those are different things, and I suspect you already know it.
But hold a second truth beside the first: he may be genuinely afraid, and frightened men tell themselves the kindest-sounding lies. I know this rather better than I'd like. I once trained a young man I loved as a brother, who kept a marriage hidden from everyone and called it protection — told himself the secrecy was for love's sake. I let myself believe his comfortable version, too. It protected no one. It rotted in the dark and took them both with it.
So — a deadline? That is the dramatic stand, and the dramatic stand is usually the lazy one. An ultimatum braced for battle buys you a date on a calendar, not the truth of his fear. Don't demand the meeting. Ask him, plainly and without an exit, what he believes will happen the day his parents learn your name. Then listen. Patience is not avoidance — but neither is pretending "Sam" is a kindness. He owes you your own name. Hold him to it, gently, and do not let him talk you out of deserving it.
— Obi-Wan Kenobi
Darth Vader weighs in
Kenobi counsels patience. Of course he does. He is fond of waiting — he waited in a desert while the galaxy burned, and called it wisdom.
Hear instead the one who lived inside the shadow he describes so calmly. I kept a marriage hidden, too. I told myself the silence was protection, that the fear in me was love. It was neither. The secret did not shield her — it became the cell I buried her in. This John does not protect you. He protects his fear, and that fear will spend your name like currency until nothing of you is left to hide. Do not wait for his courage to arrive. A love kept in the dark is already dying. Walk into the light, or make him — but do not learn this in the ash, as I did.
— Darth Vader
▸ Read next