▸ Column · Azeroth — a ranger returned from the war against the Scourge in the frozen north, answered by the Banshee Queen
SYLVANAS WINDRUNNER replies.
Replied to by Sylvanas Windrunner, with a rebuttal from Arthas Menethil.
The letter
I served two campaigns against the Scourge in the frozen north, and I came home wired wrong. The crack of ice over the eaves still drops me to the floor; I haven't slept past the fourth bell in six winters. My daughter Saela is eight now, and last week she asked her mother why Father always leaves the hall when a storm comes off the mountains — the question I've dreaded since I marched home. The temple healer says my exposure work has made real progress, but progress is not "mended," and I don't know how much to tell a child about why her father isn't the man who deployed. I told her my mind "learned some wrong lessons in the field," and she seemed to accept it — but now she whispers to the family hound whenever thunder rolls, as if sparing me the shame of her knowing. I want my family to trust me again, not tiptoe around me. How do I let them into the truth of this without making them feel they have to manage me?
Sylvanas Windrunner replies
You frame this as a dial you set — the right notch returning you to the man who deployed, trusted and untiptoed-around. Let me take that lie from you before it costs you years: there is no back. The ranger who marched north died in that snow. The one who came home is who your family has now, and grieving the other will not resurrect him. I know something of being torn from a body and not being permitted to return to it.
Now the part you have missed. Saela already knows. She whispers to the hound not to spare you embarrassment, but because no one gave her the truth, so she built her own and carries it alone in the dark. That is what secrecy breeds — not protection. Management. You fear being managed; your silence is the very thing teaching her to do it.
I rule the dead. Not one of the Forsaken came back as they were in life, and what made them mine was that I never once lied to them about what they are. Tell her plainly, at her scale. The honesty is the reconnection, not the threat to it. Stop asking permission to be what you are. No one is coming to grant it — least of all the storm.
— Sylvanas Windrunner
Arthas Menethil weighs in
Sylvanas tells you to set the terms, to ration the truth "at her scale." Of course she does. I taught her, at a cost neither of us will name here, what it is to be at another's mercy — and she has spent every year since deciding, alone, what others may be permitted to feel. That deciding-alone-what-they-can-bear is precisely my sin at Stratholme. I purged a city for its own good and asked no one. Your daughter, whispering to the hound, is the warning voice I dismissed in Uther. Do not manage her. Let her in all the way, and let her choose to carry it beside you.
— Arthas Menethil
▸ Read next