▸ Column · Mid-century Metropolis — a small-town schoolteacher writing to the advice page about a big-city society wedding
SUPERMAN replies.
Replied to by Superman, with a rebuttal from Lex Luthor.
The letter
I was over the moon when my oldest friend Cassandra asked me to be her maid of honor this fall — we've been close fifteen years. Then her list of requirements came around. Every one of her five bridesmaids has to buy the same sage-green dress from a particular boutique clear across the county, have her hair and face done by Cassandra's chosen stylist, and chip in for a getaway weekend out West, all of it adding up to more than a month of my pay. I teach art to seventh-graders. I don't have that kind of money set aside, and I still owe her a gift. When I quietly raised my budget, she said she "totally understood" — she just "wants everything to match" — which left me feeling smaller than before I spoke up. Do I empty my savings to stand beside her, or have the honest talk that might cost me the friendship?
Superman replies
Here's the part that's eating at you, friend: you told her the truth and she answered with a sigh about matching. "I totally understand" wasn't understanding. It was a polite way of leaving the bill on your side of the table. That's the thing to fix — not your savings account.
Don't empty it. And don't accept "I want everything cohesive" as an answer, because it isn't one. Go back to Cassandra and make her do the choosing she handed off to you: "Of these three — the dress, the stylist, the trip out West — which one do you truly want me in the room for? I can give you one of them. Honest. I can't give you all three." Then wait. Make her pick.
A real friend picks. A friend who can't pick one was never asking you to celebrate her — she was asking you to fund a photograph.
Where I grew up, a wedding was the whole town carrying in what it had. Nobody got a spreadsheet. You stand up there because she loves you, not because you cleared $1,400. Offer the part you can carry, and let her tell you whether it was ever you she wanted beside her.
— Superman
Lex Luthor weighs in
Oh, sweetheart. No. The alien has you negotiating a menu when the check already cleared.
You said you couldn't afford it. She said "I want it to match." That is not a woman who misheard you — that is a woman who heard you perfectly and decided the sage-green photograph outranks your rent. Charming.
One line, today: "I'm thrilled for you. Here's the number I can spend — pick what it buys. The rest is yours to solve." Then go quiet (genuinely quiet; not the wounded quiet you're rehearsing).
If a fifteen-year friendship can't survive a teacher's salary, darling, it wasn't fifteen years. It was a deposit, and she's calling it in.
— Lex Luthor
▸ Read next