▸ Column · High fantasy — Azeroth/Outland in Illidan's exile; the gratitude letter reframed as a war-displaced survivor returning to serve the temple almshouse that fed them.
ILLIDAN STORMRAGE replies.
Replied to by Illidan Stormrage, with a rebuttal from Arthas Menethil.
The letter
Three years ago I had lost everything — my position, my lodging, and what I believed was my final chance to complete my training as a healer, all inside the span of a few weeks. I slept on the floor of a kinsman's storeroom and took the night watches at a roadside waystation for coin, ate what scraps the road provided, and grew quietly certain I had ruined my own life past mending. Last month I was granted my healer's seal at last, and I have just taken a small dwelling that is, embarrassingly, entirely my own. There is a temple almshouse that kept me fed through the worst of that stretch, and I want to do something real for it — not merely leave a purse of gold, but actually appear and be of use. How do I approach the people who serve there without making it strange, or turning my gratitude into some spectacle they have to politely endure?
Illidan Stormrage replies
Eighteen months on a storeroom floor, working the night watches, certain you had broken your own life beyond repair — and you walked out the far side with the healer's craft in your hands. I know the loneliness of that road. I burned away my own eyes for power my people reviled, and my brother Malfurion sealed me in a cell for ten thousand years for walking it. So hear me on the only part of your question that troubles me. You ask how to give without "making it strange," how to keep your gratitude from becoming a performance others must manage. That is the old fear wearing a kinder mask — the dread of how you will appear — and it has no business at the door of an almshouse. They did not feed you so that you would return years later tending their comfort. Show up. Lift the crates. Let the labor be ugly, unglamorous, and unwatched. The deed is the thing; its reception is nothing. You survived the dark by working through it without applause — serve the same way. The hungry do not require you to be graceful. They require you to be there. Stop rehearsing how it looks. Go and be useful.
— Illidan Stormrage
Arthas Menethil weighs in
Stormrage tells you to arrive and simply do the work. I would tell you to arrive and first be silent. I set out to feed and save my people too — and somewhere I began deciding what they needed without ever asking. At Stratholme I decided so completely that I put my own city to the sword for its own good. The helper's certainty is where the road opens; it does not feel like a fall, it feels like duty. So do not walk in carrying your own vision of usefulness, however grateful. Ask them what they lack. Accept being told no, or "just the gold after all." The gift that wants nothing back — not even the feeling of being needed — is the only clean one. I never learned to give it. Learn it now, while it is still easy.
— Arthas Menethil
▸ Read next