▸ Column · Modern Gotham gothic noir — present-day, across the river from Park Row
BATMAN replies.
The letter
Three winters ago a man put a knife to my ribs two blocks from my old apartment in Gotham. I moved across the river. I did the counseling. I did everything they told me. And I still throw both deadbolts and check under the bed every night before my body will let me sleep. My partner, Theo, wants us to move in together and calls the routine "a little much." I keep telling him it is not irrational — it is the thing between me and a 2 a.m. spiral — but he keeps saying I should be "past this by now." Last week he moved my doorstop, my third layer on the front door, into the hall closet without telling me. I did not sleep. I love Theo. But I cannot tell anymore whether I am asking for something reasonable, or whether the walls I built to keep me safe have quietly become a cell with two of us inside it.
Batman replies
A man put a knife to you. Your body learned the lesson. Mine learned one in an alley off Park Row. Pearls on wet pavement. I was eight. No one is ever "past it." You build a life around the not-being-past-it. I built mine in a cave.
Hear me. The deadbolts are not pathology. They are preparation. Checking the room before you sleep is what a survivor does when the city has already shown its hand once. Do not let anyone shame you out of your own perimeter.
But examine the question you are actually asking. Armor lets you move. A cell does not. If the ritual ends your night, it is armor. If it runs your night, it has become the thing it was built to stop. Be honest about which.
Then look at Theo. He reached into your home and removed a lock while you slept. He did not ask. He disarmed you. That is not a man helping you heal. That is a man deciding which of your defenses he will permit.
Watch him. Move in slowly, if at all. The night is darkest before the dawn. Make certain he is not the dark.
— Batman
Catwoman weighs in
Bruce. The man with a panic room for the whole planet, lecturing a knife-survivor on "armor versus cell." Adorable.
Here is the part he circled and would not land on, sugar: Theo did not "gently suggest." He walked into your home and stole your lock while you were asleep. That is not a healing partner. That is a man auditing which of your needs he intends to allow.
So keep one bolt he never gets a key to. Move in slow, or not at all — your name, your lease, your exit. The doorstop was never the cage. The man who keeps quietly moving it is.
— Catwoman
▸ Read next