▸ Column · Azeroth — a noble family's inheritance dispute over an ancestral lakeside hall, the contested testament of a father who died under his son's stewardship
SYLVANAS WINDRUNNER replies.
Replied to by Sylvanas Windrunner, with a rebuttal from Arthas Menethil.
The letter
My father died four moons ago and left our family's lakeside hall — where we gathered every summer of my childhood — entirely to my younger brother Declan. My sister Renata and I were each left a purse of coin worth perhaps a third of the hall's value apiece. Father never spoke of changing his testament. When I pressed Declan, he turned evasive and said only that Father "trusted him to manage things," which explains nothing. Declan held my father's authority and seal through the last two years of his illness, and Renata is certain he leaned on a dying man to bend the will. I cannot tell whether she is right or whether grief has us both seeing daggers in shadows. I loved my father. I have no wish to spend a decade at war with my brother over a building — yet I cannot shake the sense that something crooked happened, and that we are simply meant to smile and let it pass.
Sylvanas Windrunner replies
Hear the lie buried in your own words: "simply meant to smile and let it pass." Meant by whom? The arrangement that strips you was not handed down by some fair and watching power. It was written under the hand of the one man in the room — your brother, who held your father's seal while your father was too sick to wield it himself. That is where power sat. Not with you, not with Renata, not with sentiment. With Declan, and with the silence he is now selling you as "trust."
So stop asking whether grief deceives you, and go and learn. Demand the records — when the will was altered, who witnessed it, who drew the scribe. Evasion that asks you to take it on faith is not an answer; it is a man counting on your grief to make you obedient. My own sisters and I were divided by far crueler hands, and I have learned that what you do not examine, you consent to.
But mark this — I will not feed you a decade of war that hollows you out and leaves Declan living comfortably in the hall while you rot beside the wound. Get the truth first. Let the truth, not your fury, decide the cost you are willing to pay.
— Sylvanas Windrunner
Arthas Menethil weighs in
She tells you to learn the truth. Good. But watch what she skips past — the word "certain." Renata is certain. The Banshee Queen would have you certain too, seal and scribe marshalled to confirm the verdict you have already half-passed. I know that certainty. I rode to the frozen end of the world on it, sure I served justice, and the people who loved me called me cold, and they were right. Ask the records your questions, yes. But do not ask only whether Declan is guilty. Ask what a decade at war with your brother over a building would make of you — and whether the man who returns from that war is one your father would still know.
— Arthas Menethil
▸ Read next