▸ Column · Modern day, Professor X answering as headmaster of his school for the gifted — a telepath fielding a letter about a depleting one-sided friendship
PROFESSOR X replies.
Replied to by Professor X, with a rebuttal from Magneto.
The letter
Headmaster — my closest friend from our academy years and I have been inseparable for a decade, but for the last two the friendship has become a single unbroken rescue. Every conversation is three hours of me talking her down from the same crises: the rotating cast of people who treat her badly, a posting she loathes but won't leave, a feud with her landlord she's been "about to escalate" since forever. The instant I mention anything in my own life, she says "totally — anyway," and is back to herself inside thirty seconds; I've started timing it, which I know is a grim little habit. Last month I finally told her I'd been struggling, badly, and had started seeing someone for it. She answered with a long message wondering whether an ex had noticed her latest post. I love her. I don't want to detonate ten years over this. But I've begun to dread her name lighting up my phone, and I suspect that means something. Is there a way to actually say this to her without it becoming one more emergency I'm summoned to fix?
Professor X replies
You have already done the hardest thing, which is to notice — and then to be honest enough to admit that the dread frightens you. Hold onto that honesty; it is the whole game.
Now let me ask the question I always ask first. A person who cannot bear thirty seconds of silence about anyone but herself is rarely selfish in the way the word implies. She is, far more often, terrified — that if she stops performing the crisis, she will discover she is not interesting enough to keep. People are almost always more frightened than they are cruel, and Daria sounds less cruel than drowning.
That does not obligate you to drown beside her. Here is the line I have spent my life walking, sometimes badly. There is a man I have loved like a brother since we were young, and I learned with him that stepping back to survive someone is not the same as deciding they are beyond reach. So say it plainly and lovingly: "I cannot be your only shore, and lately I've needed one myself." Then mean the boundary. Make room for her to actually ask after you — and notice, honestly, whether she ever does. You may step back. Leave the door unlatched while you do.
— Professor X
Magneto weighs in
Charles, you have found the frightened child under the behavior, as you always do — and missed that you are advising the one person in this story with no power to spend more of it.
Look at the structure, not the wound. Your friend possesses a resource — your attention, your hours, your steadiness — and Daria draws on it endlessly and pays nothing. That is not a friendship. It is a tribute. "Say it lovingly and leave the door open" is the sedative; she will absorb the speech as one more crisis and resume the withdrawal.
Stop petitioning her to value you. Simply cease subsidizing her. Spend your hours where they are returned. When the account she drained freely runs dry, she will, for the first time, feel its cost — and only then learn what you were ever worth. Let her.
— Magneto
▸ Read next